Why This Case Matters
For a young person, a single arrest can feel like the end of everything they have worked toward. College, financial aid, a future career—all of it can seem to hang in the balance before they have even finished growing up. But an arrest is not a conviction, and it is not even a formal charge. This case shows why the period right after an arrest—before the State ever files charges—can be the most important window of all.
Many people don’t realize that being arrested and being charged are two different things. After an arrest, the State Attorney’s Office independently reviews the case and decides whether to formally prosecute. That decision is not automatic—and it can be influenced.
For our client, a college student, that distinction made all the difference.
![]()
What Happened
What HappenedOur client, a college student, was pulled over in Broward County for a window tint violation—a routine traffic stop. During the stop, officers reported seeing a small baggie of cocaine in plain view in the vehicle’s center console.
But our client was not alone. A passenger was seated in the front seat, equally close to the same console.
Both occupants were questioned. Neither admitted that the drugs were theirs. And with cocaine in a shared area of the car and no one claiming it, officers arrested both of them.
That arrest alone exposed our client to serious, life-altering consequences:
- A third-degree felony charge for possession of cocaine, punishable by up to five years in prison
- A permanent felony drug record, following him long after college
- Loss of eligibility for financial aid and potential university disciplinary action
- Lasting damage to his future career and professional opportunities
For a student with his whole life ahead of him, a drug felony threatened to close doors before they ever opened.
Our Strategic Approach
Rather than waiting for the State to file formal charges and fighting the case afterward, Dave went to work during the pre-file period—the window after an arrest when the State Attorney’s Office is still deciding whether to prosecute.
His argument focused on a core principle of Florida drug law: possession requires dominion and control.
This involved:
- Attacking constructive possession. To convict, the State must prove not just that drugs were nearby, but that our client knew about them and had the ability to control them. Dave argued the State could not make that showing.
- Emphasizing the jointly occupied vehicle. The cocaine sat in a center console accessible to both the driver and the passenger. When two people share equal access to a common area, Florida law does not allow possession to be inferred from mere proximity.
- Highlighting the absence of any admission. Neither occupant claimed the drugs, and nothing tied them to our client rather than the passenger. Without that link, the State’s case could not stand.
The Result: No Charges Filed
After reviewing Dave’s argument, the State Attorney’s Office declined to move forward. The outcome:
- No formal charges filed—a decision known as a “no information”
- No felony prosecution
- No conviction and no plea
- The case ended before it ever became a formal court case
- Eligibility to pursue expungement of the arrest record, clearing the arrest itself from his history
- Our client’s record and future left intact
Because charges were never filed, our client avoided not only a conviction, but the prosecution itself. And because the case resolved with a no information, he became eligible to petition to expunge the arrest record entirely—so the arrest itself can be erased from his history.
Why This Outcome Mattered
A drug felony can follow a young person for the rest of their life—affecting where they can go to school, whether they qualify for aid, and what careers remain open to them. Our client wasn’t asking for special treatment. He was asking not to be held responsible for something the evidence could not show was his.
By stepping in early and holding the State to its burden, Dave helped ensure that a single traffic stop did not define his client’s future.
For a college student, keeping this case from ever being filed was the best outcome imaginable.
If You or Your Child Was Arrested but Not Yet Charged in Broward County, Act Now
The time between an arrest and a filing decision is short—and it is often the best opportunity to keep charges from ever being filed. Once the State formally charges a case, the options narrow. Acting early can make all the difference.
At the Law Offices of Dave L. Simmons, P.A., we understand how much is at stake when a young person is arrested—especially in drug cases that can affect education, financial aid, and career. With decades of experience, including prior service as both a Broward State Attorney and Public Defender, we know how to challenge a case before it ever reaches the courtroom in Fort Lauderdale and surrounding areas—including Lauderhill, Plantation, Coral Springs, and Pembroke Pines. Contact our office today at 954-765-3540 for a confidential consultation.
Note: Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. The specific facts and circumstances of your case will determine the available defense strategies and potential outcomes.
